---
title: "Is the Education System Outmoded?"
description: "Is the education system outmoded? If students are doing schoolwork with Artificial Intelligence (AI) and teachers are using AI to grade assignments, what good…"
url: https://www.independentpress.com/article/is-the-education-system-outmoded
date: 2026-02-09
categories: ["Education","Technology"]
author: "By Selise Phillips"
---

# Is the Education System Outmoded?

![Is the Education System Outmoded?](https://images.ctfassets.net/ewtdlsoyixc1/3qy1gqBc0536BJjmdM6yk3/557fcc371c62363f614b287b34f0ce9e/Edu_-_5.jpg)

**Introduction**

Is the education system outmoded? If students are doing schoolwork with Artificial Intelligence (AI) and teachers are using AI to grade assignments, what good is school? Much of education – writing English papers, answering prompts, solving math problems – can now be performed by AI. Not only are students using AI to complete assignments, but teachers are also using AI to create curriculum, grade assignments, and increase student engagement. According to a report released by the Center for Democracy and Technology, “eighty-five percent of teachers and 86% of students used AI in the 2024–2025 school year.”i  But, as the use of AI in classrooms has become increasingly more common, data has started to suggest that the more you use AI for everyday matters the greater the risk it poses to your intellectual development. The reliance that both students and educators now place on AI may in effect be leading to stagnation and even regression in our education system.

**How AI is Used in Education**

Educators have increasingly implemented AI into their curriculum and in the development of their lesson plans. Teachers have started to employ AI to help design classroom curriculum and to automate mundane administrative tasks.iiAI has simplified everyday tasks including grading tests, papers, and homework, scheduling classes and assignments, and communicating with students and faculty. Many educators have also, intentional or unintentional, started to use AI as the standard of review. Teachers will often plug a prewritten essay into AI “to see how the AI would have written it” and then compare and contrast the two papers.iii

The most common way students, especially high schoolers, use AI is by writing essays, not just through ChatGPT, but also through AI tools like Grammarly, Gemini, and Microsoft Copilot. According to College Board, between January and May of 2025, the number of high school students who use AI tools grew from 79% to 84%.iv The use of AI by students in higher education is just as pervasive. According to a global survey by the Digital Education Council, 86% of college students use AI in their studies.v College students primarily use AI to brainstorm ideas, paraphrase documents, edit or revise essays, and to conduct research and find sources.vi

**Benefits & Costs of Using AI**

AI is being used across the education system, from high school to college and by students and teachers. Faculty report using AI to save time and energy on everyday administrative duties and to design “more effective and engaging curricula by analyzing student data, identifying learning gaps, and suggesting relevant sources.”vii AI can also help to personalize learning for individual students. AI is being used to “tailor content, pacing, and activities to each student’s learning style and preferences, creating a more individualized and effective learning experience.”viii Besides personalized learning, AI also offers students interactive engagement and real-time feedback.

Unquestionably, AI offers to the education system. However, becoming overly dependent on AI tools for learning may be detrimental to the intellectual and professional development of both students and teachers. For one, AI eliminates the requirement that teachers use their own instructional experience to develop lesson plans adapted for students. It also removes the need for teachers to individually assess the work of their students. AI grades off a rubric, analyzing student submissions against criteria that is created and pre-defined by educators. When grading with AI, output is programmed so feedback is more mechanical than the human touch. As such, AI creates a very systemized and programmed approach to education.ix

A mechanical approach to education could be problematic. Take for example the use of AI rubrics for grading. In granting an AI rubric superiority as the standard for review, you eliminate the stylistic nuance and creativity involved in individual writing and you also make it difficult for nonnative English speakers to meet the measuring stick. Most “major LLMs [Large Language Models] are predominantly trained using English data.”x The result may be exclusionary to nonnative speakers, as some languages are not as digitized as others, making it harder for AI to adapt to less dominant vernaculars.xi Further, an excessive dependance on AI cultivates an environment that puts less attention on the essential relationship between educators and scholars. According to Panashe Goteka from the Mobile Guardian, a heavy reliance on AI, specifically AI tutors, could “diminish the vital role of human teachers in fostering critical thinking, social interaction, and emotional development.”xii Guidance and instruction from teachers is necessary for students to grow not only academically but also emotionally. Educators, especially in high school, are extremely influential in the way students learn and in helping young students understand how important education is to their future.

The very presence of AI in the education systems is counterintuitive to intellectual growth. If both teachers and students are placing their utmost trust and reliance on AI, what incentive do you have to use your brain? Having the skill to edit and revise your own writing rather than relying on AI tools gives you greater proficiency for recognizing and correcting mistakes. The ability to identify and amend one’s own errors is important to human development and the maturation process of becoming an adult. 

Trial and error are crucial for developing real-world skills and for filtering out misinformation. Unfortunately, the large and growing number of students relying on AI for everyday matters is allowing misinformation to proliferate. According to journalist Paul McQuiston in USC Today, “college students are increasingly turning to AI tools to get quick answers rather than deepen their understanding.”xiii Although getting a surface-level understanding of a topic can save time and effort, using AI to do so may result in getting inaccurate and inconclusive information. In a common phenomenon known as hallucinations, AI will respond with information that is completely made up.xiv Erroneous material spreads fast, and AI may not have the capability to discern fact from fiction.xv 

**Effects on Cognitive Development & Mental Health**

Some fear that overreliance on AI could affect the cognitive development of users. “Emerging research suggests that the more you use AI, the more it may negatively affect your critical thinking skills.”xvi An MIT study showed that people who relied on ChatGPT for writing essays “demonstrated much lower electrical connectivity in their brains.”xvii In relying on AI for critical thinking, it is highly plausible that we are stagnating the neural networks in our brains and damaging the cognitive skills that make humans so unique as a species.

AI is not only a potential threat to the cognitive development of students, but it is also a significant danger to their mental health. A study performed by Ryan Nagelhout with Harvard’s Graduate School of Education found that out of the 1,500 teens surveyed several described “using generative tools to create voices and images that can be used to enhance bullying in and out of school.”xviii AI-generated videos, audio, or images, called deepfakes, that impersonate individuals making them appear to do and say things they never have, can make bullying easier by allowing lies to become more believable and misinformation to spread more quickly.xix Heather Hollingsworth with Associated Press writes that AI deepfakes, especially ones containing inappropriate images, tend to go “viral and then continue to resurface,” causing “a cycle of trauma” for the victim.xx High schools and colleges are struggling to combat bullying, deepfakes, and misinformation in the classroom. In this way, AI is directly contributing toincreased stress levels among students and potentially affecting their academic performance.

**Conclusion**

Where does this leave education? Are we doomed to fall prey to AI’s grasp, remain as luddites, or is there a potential middle ground? One thing is clear, though AI offers significant benefits to human learning, it should not be the end-all decision maker. Nor should AI be any more than a resource to teachers and students that complements learning. Going forward, it should be mandatory that all school assignments are handwritten, in class, with the use of AI prohibited. This is the only way to ensure students are exercising their brains and not ChatGPT. It is also crucial, in a world where bullying and school shootings are ever present, that teachers establish strong connections with their students. Relying on AI as a substitute for social connections is a huge mistake. Human connection and feedback are essential for emotional development. Human interaction, mental rigor, positive feedback, trial and error are important facets of human life that AI cannot replicate. It is important, as AI continues to evolve in our society, that we understand its benefits and limitations and carve off sections of our society and our humanity based on empathy and solidarity rather than mechanical programming. AI may be able to help us extend our reach in the universe, but it can never be the prime actor less we risk losing our own humanity.
